HABIB JOHNSON v. MYDATT SERVS., INC., d/b/a BLOCK BY BLOCK

HABIB JOHNSON v. MYDATT SERVS., INC., d/b/a BLOCK BY BLOCK, No. WC26-6636 (W.C.C.A. September 8, 2026).

In this case heard by the Workers’ Compensation Court of Appeals, two issues were before the Court. First, whether the compensation judge’s findings and ultimate conclusion that the Employee failed to prove the October 27, 2022, work injury substantially caused or substantially aggravated his mental health conditions was flawed. And whether the compensation judge’s findings and ultimate conclusion that the Employee failed to prove the October 27, 2022, work injury led to consequential injuries to the low back and left hip.

The employee was traveling on a bicycle for work when he was struck on the left side by a motor vehicle coming out of a parking garage. He refused medical treatment at the time of the incident and continued to work for the employer for a number of months after the injury.

On December 7, 2022, the employee sought treatment for left knee pain which he attributed to the work injury. He treated with a chiropractor for over a year with no mention of low back or left hip pain. In March of 2023, the employee was seen at Summit Orthopedics, and at a evaluation on May 22, 2023, the first mention of back pain was recorded in the review of symptoms sections. No treatment was discussed regarding the low back, only the left knee.

On July 26, 2023, Dr. Mark Engasser performed an independent medical examination on the employee at the request of the employer and insurer. At that time, the employee reported low back pain due to the crutches he was using. Dr. Engasser noted crutches had not been prescribed for the employee’s injury. Dr. Engasser found no evidence of a low back injury.

In the fall of 2023, the employee began seeking psychological treatment for adjustment disorder, mixed anxiety and depressed mood. He was only seen twice by this provider, and then in December 2023, was evaluated by another therapist who opined the employee would benefit from discussing issues regarding anesthesia before undergoing surgery. In April of 2024, the employee began seeing a different therapist and reported his stress and anxiety were caused by instability with housing and finances after his work injury.

Subsequently, the employee went back to Summit Orthopedics in May of 2024, and mentioned left hip and back pain along with his left knee pain. He was then referred to other providers due to a labral tear of the left hip. Physical therapy and injections were recommended for his left hip, but surgery was not. In April of 2025, the employee was also seen in the ER for falling three times in two weeks. He attributed the falls to his work injury.

In June of 2025, the employee underwent two independent medical exams, one psychological and one orthopedic. At the psychological evaluation, the employee decided not to complete any written testing. He was diagnosed with adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood, moderate cannabis use disorder, and antisocial personality traits. None of these diagnoses were attributed to the work injury. The orthopedic provider, after viewing surveillance videos of the employee which may have indicated the employee was misrepresenting his physical capabilities, diagnosed a left knee lateral muscle tear, but found no objective evidence of hip and low back pain.

Subsequently, the employee’s attorney requested three narrative reports. The first indicated the employee had a left hip labrum tear, osteoarthritis of the left hip, and a left hip contusion, substantially contributed to by the work injury. The second narrative diagnosed the employee with a left hip labral tear, L4-5 disc herniation, a meniscal tear, a partial PCL tear of the left knee, PTSD, and adjustment disorder all consistent with the employee’s work injury. The third narrative report listed similar injuries all attributed to the work injury.

At a hearing on December 30, 2025, the judge adopted the views of the IMEs of the employer and insurer. The judge ruled the employee failed to prove he sustained a consequential hip or back injury, and also failed to prove any mental health consequential injury. The employee appealed.

The employee argued that the mental health IME lacked foundation because he did not complete written testing, and should not have been adopted because the IME provider was not a board certified forensic psychologist. The WCCA ruled the expert opinion lacks foundation when: 1) when the opinion does not include the facts upon which the expert is relying for his opinion, 2) there is no explanation of the basis of the opinion, or 3) the facts assumed by the expert are not supported by the evidence. In addition, the WCCA opined, qualifications of the witness go to the weight of the testimony not the admissibility.

The employee also argued on appeal for the first time that the opinions of experts regarding the orthopedic injuries lack foundation. However, the WCCA ruled when there is no objection to a medical expert at hearing, allegations of defects go to the weight of the opinion.

The WCCA went on to review the findings of the compensation judge in both the mental health injury and consequential orthopedic injuries and found substantial evidence supported the findings of the compensation judge, whose findings and conclusions were affirmed.

Takeaway:  When considering the foundation of an expert witness report, the qualifications of the expert go to the weight of the report not the admissibility. When submitting an IME report, the reasons behind the opinions are as important as the opinion itself.