Edin Peralta-Hernandez v. Pahl Exteriors, LLC, et.al

Edin Peralta-Hernandez v. Pahl Exteriors, LLC, et.al, No. WC26-6633 (W.C.C.A. September 22, 2026)

The Employee sustained injuries while employed by Pahl Exteriors on October 4, 2023, who was uninsured for workers’ compensation liability insurance; the Special Compensation Fund was named in lieu of an insurer given this who filed an answer denying the Employee’s claims for benefits. After investigation, ME Roofing, who was a subcontractor of Pahl Exteriors who possibly hired the Employee was added as a party along with their insurer. ME Roofing entered into separate Stipulations for Settlement with the plentiful intervenors and the Employee; neither Pahl Exteriors or the SCF participated or signed any Stipulation.

The Stipulation between ME Roofing and the Employee contained a holding harmless and indemnification provision for any claims for contribution or reimbursement. After the Award came in, SCF filed a Petition for Reimbursement which ME Roofing objected to. A hearing on the matter took place and the Compensation Judge denied SCF’s Petition for Reimbursement, dismissing ME Roofing as a party on the basis that the Employee entered into a valid Pierringer settlement. SCF appealed this decision.

The WCCA considered a jurisdictional argument as a part of their analysis. SCF argued ME Roofing needed to be a party for determination on whether they were an employer. The WCCA found this unpersuasive as this can be accomplished without having ME Roofing at the hearing and that the arguments presented by SCF at the hearing did not present factual issues that required an evidentiary hearing. The only “issues of material facts” is who the employer was on the claimed date of injury, for which ME Roofing is not a necessary party to the determination of that issue since no party presented witnesses for testimony. SCF further argued the petition for reimbursement also could include statutory penalties and costs not included in the indemnity agreement; the WCCA pointed out SCF had no statutory claims against ME Roofing since they carried workers’ compensation insurance. SCF also argued the indemnity provision did not apply to SCF since they were not an insurer. Again, the WCCA dismissed this argument as the indemnity provision provided indemnity to any “party or person” and they held that SCF was a party in this instance.

The WCCA then considered the Pierringer settlement argument that SCF had wherein Pierringer settlements are not appropriate where the effect is to prejudice non-settling parties. The WCCA refused to address this particular argument. SCF then argued that this sort of settlement shifted liability to an otherwise non-liable party. This was a hearing on whether the Employee was entitled to benefits from Pahl if Pahl was the Employer on the claimed date of injury. If Pahl was found to be the Employer in fact, there is no harm from the Pierringer settlement between the Employee and ME Roofing. Alternatively, though, if ME Roofing was found to be the Employer, there is no harm in the particular settlement as the Fund would not be required to make any payments. The WCCA held there was no compelling argument presented by the SCF that ME Roofing’s settlement with the Employee in any way prejudiced SCF as requiring an employer to be subject to the costs of ongoing litigation despite a settlement is contrary to workers’ compensation principles. Specifically, settlements should be favored to avoid litigation delay and to grant expedited relief.

They affirmed the compensation judge’s denial of SCF’s Motion for Reimbursement.

Takeaway: Pierringer may be an option for employers and insurers of multi-party cases to separately settle out should the circumstances align.